Refuting Islam

📖 Qur’anic Contradictions: Part 2 – Scientific and Logical Failures

When the “Final Revelation” collapses under reason, reality, and its own words.

📘 Introduction

The Quran claims to be a book of wisdom, truth, and divine clarity. But in its pages are contradictions against logic, science, and itself.

These aren’t interpretation debates — they’re observable falsehoods and internal conflicts that destroy the claim of divine authorship.

6️⃣ How Long Did Creation Take?

6 Days:

“Your Lord created the heavens and the earth in six days…” — 7:54, 10:3, 11:7, 25:59
8 Days (when broken down):

41:9–12:
- 2 days to create the earth
- 4 days for sustenance
- 2 more days for the heavens
  ➤ 2 + 4 + 2 = 8 days

📌 Contradiction: Both cannot be true — simple math exposes divine error.

🧠 Implication: Either Allah miscounted — or the book is man-made.

7️⃣ Where Does Semen Come From?

“He is created from a fluid, gushing forth, issuing from between the backbone and the ribs.” — 86:6–7

📌 Scientific error: Semen is produced in the testicles, stored in the vas deferens — nowhere near the spine or ribs.

🧠 Implication: The Quran gets human biology wrong — not a mistake an all-knowing creator would make.

8️⃣ Is the Earth Flat or Spherical?

Flattened Earth Verses:

“And the earth, We have spread it out…” — 15:19
“And after that, He spread the earth (dahaha).” — 79:30
“Do they not look… how the earth is spread out?” — 88:20

📌 “Dahaha” literally refers to flattening, not shaping into a sphere.
All early tafsir (Ibn Kathir, al-Jalalayn) affirm a flat-Earth model.

🧠 Implication: The Quran reflects 7th-century cosmology — not divine omniscience.

9️⃣ Free Will vs. Predestination

Free Will Promised:

“Let him who wills believe, and let him who wills disbelieve.” — 18:29
“He inspired it (the soul) to its wickedness and righteousness.” — 91:7–10
Yet Allah Controls Belief:

“None can believe except by Allah’s permission.” — 10:100
“Allah guides whom He wills, and misguides whom He wills.” — 14:4, 6:125

📌 Contradiction: If belief is up to the person — why is Allah blamed for misguidance?

🧠 Implication: Moral incoherence — people are punished for choices they were never allowed to make.

🔟 Can Jinn (Made of Fire) Be Punished by Fire?

Made of fire:

“And the jinn We created before from scorching fire.” — 15:27
Punished in hellfire:

“Surely We have created many jinn and humans for Hell…” — 7:179

📌 Contradiction of substance: How does fire burn fire?

🧠 Implication: Either jinn are spiritual and the fire is metaphorical (which contradicts other literal hell passages), or the punishment is illogical.

🧪 Summary Table: Scientific & Logical Contradictions

Contradiction	Core Problem
6 vs. 8 days of creation	Mathematical inconsistency
Semen origin (backbone/ribs)	Anatomical falsehood
Flat vs. spherical Earth	Cosmological error
Free will vs. predestination	Moral incoherence
Fire-based jinn punished by fire	Logical absurdity

📢 Coming Next:

📖 Qur’anic Contradictions: Part 3 – Timeline, Narrative, and Identity Conflicts

Was the Earth or the heavens created first?
Does the Quran say there's compulsion in religion — or not?
Does Pharaoh drown or survive?
Is the Quran clear — or in constant need of scholars to explain?

👁 Contradictions in story, timeline, and textual structure — all waiting to be exposed.