Refuting Islam

📖 Qur’anic Contradictions Series Overview

❌ Surah 4:82 — “If it had been from other than Allah, they would have found many contradictions in it.”

Now we do find them — by the dozen.

🔥 Part 1: Theological Chaos

Contradictions about Jesus, God’s nature, and doctrinal consistency.

🔹 1. Who Was the First Muslim?

6:14, 6:163, 39:12 — Muhammad says “I am the first to submit.”
7:143 — Moses says “I am the first of the believers.”
2:131 — Abraham submits first.
26:51 — The followers of Moses say “We are the first of the believers.”
📌 Internal contradiction in spiritual primacy — either one man was first, or all were.

🔹 2. Was Jesus Killed or Not?

4:157 — “They did not kill him, nor crucify him.”
3:55 — Allah says to Jesus, “I will cause you to die and raise you to Myself.”
19:33 — Jesus says: “Peace on me the day I was born, the day I die, and the day I am raised.”
5:117 — Jesus says, “You took me after my mission was done.”

📌 Contradiction between substitution theory and texts implying real death.

🔹 3. Is the Bible Corrupted or Preserved?

5:47 — “Let the People of the Gospel judge by what Allah revealed therein.”
10:94 — Muhammad told to consult “those who read the Book before you.”
6:34, 6:115 — “No one can alter the words of Allah.”
Muslims claim corruption — the Quran denies it.

📌 Either Allah’s word was preserved (Quran) or it was not (Islamic tradition).

🔹 4. How Many Angels Spoke to Mary?

3:42–45 — “The angels said...” (plural)
19:17–19 — “We sent her Our spirit, and he said...” (singular, Gabriel)
📌 Contradiction in divine messenger identity.

🔹 5. Is Jesus the Same as Isa?

Quran treats Isa as a prophet only — not crucified, not divine
Gospel Jesus is crucified, claims divinity, rises again
📌 Historical contradiction: no evidence of “Isa” ever existing — only Jesus.
Islam rebrands Jesus to fit its narrative — no theological continuity.

🧪 Part 2: Scientific and Logical Failures

Contradictions with observable science, reason, and basic coherence.

🔹 6. How Long Did Creation Take?

7:54, 10:3, 11:7, 25:59 — 6 days
41:9–12 — Breaks it into 4 + 2 + 2 = 8 days
📌 Numerical contradiction from the same author.

🔹 7. Where Does Semen Come From?

86:6–7 — “Created from a fluid, issuing from between the backbone and the ribs.”
📌 Medically inaccurate — semen is produced in testes, not the ribcage or spine.
Scientific error = contradiction to observable fact

🔹 8. Is the Earth Flat or Round?

88:20 — “And the earth — how it is spread out?”
15:19, 78:6, 79:30 — flattened, spread like a carpet
📌 Consistent flat-earth cosmology, contradicting reality.
Later apologetic reinterpretation is retrofitted — not textual.

🔹 9. Free Will vs. Predestination

18:29, 91:7–10 — Humans are free to choose
6:125, 10:100, 14:4 — Allah chooses whom He guides or misguides
📌 Moral contradiction: humans are punished for Allah’s own choices.

🔹 10. Jinns Made of Fire — Yet Burn in Hell?

15:27 — Jinns made from smokeless fire
7:179 — Jinns go to Hell (fire-based punishment)
📌 Material contradiction: How does fire torment fire?

📜 Part 3: Timeline, Narrative, and Identity Conflicts

Historical inconsistencies, order-of-creation errors, and confused characters.

🔹 11. Creation Order Contradiction

2:29 — Earth made for man, then the heavens
79:27–30 — Heaven made first, then Earth spread
📌 The Quran contradicts itself on the creation sequence.

🔹 12. Is There Compulsion in Religion?

2:256 — “There is no compulsion in religion.”
9:5 — “Kill the polytheists wherever you find them.”
9:29 — “Fight those who do not believe... until they pay the jizya.”
📌 Contradiction in legal doctrine: either faith is free, or it’s forced under threat.

🔹 13. Can Sins Be Forgiven or Not?

4:48 — “Allah does not forgive shirk.”
4:110, 39:53 — “He forgives all sins.”
📌 Contradiction: absolute forgiveness vs. an unforgivable sin.

🔹 14. Pharaoh Drowned or Saved?

10:92 — “We shall save your body...”
17:103, 28:40, 43:55 — “We drowned him.”
📌 Contradiction: was Pharaoh’s body preserved, or was he destroyed?

🔹 15. Is the Quran Clear or Needing Tafsir?

12:1–2, 16:89, 41:3 — “Clear Arabic Quran… explanation of all things.”
Yet Muslims rely on massive volumes of tafsir, often disagreeing
📌 Self-refuting claim — if it's clear, why is it incomprehensible without scholars?

✅ Final Word: 3-Part Series Impact

Part	Focus	Damage Delivered
📖 Part 1 – Theological Chaos	Identity of prophets, scripture, God’s message	Discredits theological continuity
📖 Part 2 – Scientific & Logical Failures	Science, reason, internal logic	Destroys divine authorship claims
📖 Part 3 – Narrative Contradictions	History, laws, doctrine	Exposes confusion and inconsistency