Refuting Islam

🔥 15 Debate Questions Muslims Can’t Answer – Part 1

A tactical dismantling of Islamic doctrine using only its own sources

📘 Introduction

This isn’t a hit-piece. It’s a logical minefield, built entirely from Islam’s own texts—the Quran, Sahih Hadith, and classical fiqh. These 15 questions are not speculative or emotional. They are doctrinal traps that force Muslims to either:

Contradict their own scripture,
Admit inconsistency, or
Flee the conversation.

Every question is backed by textual evidence, with no reliance on Western values, philosophy, or emotional rhetoric. Just Islam versus Islam.

❓ 1. Can Allah’s words be changed or not?

Quran 6:115 – “None can alter the words of Allah.”
Quran 18:27 – “None can change His words.”

Yet Muslims claim the Torah and Gospel were changed by Jews and Christians. But these books are referred to as Allah’s revelations in:

Quran 5:46–47 – Jesus was given the Gospel.
Quran 3:3 – The Torah and Gospel were sent down as guidance and light.

🔍 Contradiction:
If the Torah and Gospel were changed, then Allah’s words were altered.
If they weren’t changed, then Islam contradicts their message (e.g., the crucifixion, divinity of Jesus).

📌 Conclusion: Either the Quran contradicts itself, or the entire Islamic claim of corruption is false.

❓ 2. If the Gospel was real, why did it vanish?

Quran 5:47 commands Christians to judge by “what Allah has revealed” in the Gospel.

But Muslims claim the Gospel given to Jesus has been lost, replaced with corrupted accounts.

🔍 Logical trap:
Why would Allah command Christians to follow a scripture that no longer exists?

📌 Conclusion: Either the Gospel existed and Islam contradicts it, or it didn’t—and Allah is commanding the impossible.

❓ 3. If Islam is perfect, why can’t any Islamic country apply it without violating basic human rights?

Across history and today, Islamic states under full or partial Sharia have implemented:

Death for apostasy (Iran, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan)
Child marriage (Yemen, Pakistan)
Legal inferiority for non-Muslims and women
Blasphemy laws punishable by death or prison

📌 Conclusion: If these are Islamic, then Islam is incompatible with human dignity. If they’re un-Islamic, then no Islamic country in history has ever “done Islam right.”

❓ 4. Why does a ‘clear book’ require endless interpretation?

Quran 12:1, 26:2, 43:2 – “These are the verses of the clear book.”

But Islamic law and theology require:

Thousands of tafsirs (commentaries),
Volumes of Hadith to explain its meaning,
And centuries of scholarly dispute.

📌 Contradiction: A book that requires outside explanation is not clear.

❓ 5. Why did Muhammad marry a child?

Sahih Bukhari 7:62:64 – “The Prophet married her when she was six years old and consummated the marriage when she was nine.”

This Hadith is:

Authentic, found in Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawud, etc.
Unanimously accepted by classical scholars like Ibn Hajar, Al-Nawawi, and Ibn Kathir.

📌 Trap: If Muhammad’s example is perfect (Quran 33:21), then child marriage is moral. If it’s not moral today, then Muhammad is not the best example for all time.

❓ 6. Why does the “peaceful religion” contain the Sword Verse?

Quran 9:5 – “Kill the polytheists wherever you find them…”

This verse:

Was revealed late in Muhammad’s life (Medinan period).
Abrogated more peaceful verses like 2:256 (“no compulsion”), according to classical tafsir (e.g., Ibn Kathir).

📌 Conclusion: Either Islam is peaceful and 9:5 should be rejected (contradicting scholars), or Islam is inherently violent.

❓ 7. Name a single Sunni or Shia school that doesn’t prescribe death for apostates.

Answer: You can’t.

All major legal schools — Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi’i, Hanbali, and Ja’fari — require execution for apostasy unless the apostate repents.

📌 Conclusion: If death for apostasy is “not real Islam,” then Islam has been wrong for 1,400 years.

❓ 8. Why is violence needed to enforce Sharia if there’s “no compulsion in religion”?

Quran 2:256 – “There is no compulsion in religion.”
But:

Quran 9:29 commands fighting non-Muslims until they submit and pay jizya.
Sharia punishes:
- Apostates with death,
- Blasphemers with death,
- Non-compliance with lashings or amputations.

📌 Conclusion: Islam is compulsory by force—religion backed by violence.

❓ 9. Why does Allah need Muslims to wage war for Him?

If Allah is all-powerful, why does He require:

Armed jihad,
Beheadings (Quran 8:12),
Human enforcement of divine law?

📌 Conclusion: Either Allah is weak, or this is a human system disguised as divine command.

❓ 10. Why restrict the final revelation to Arabic?

Quran 41:44 – “If We had sent this as a Quran in a foreign language, they would have said, ‘Why are its verses not explained in our language?’”

But if it’s a universal religion, why:

Send the final message in one tribal dialect,
To one region,
In one time period?

📌 Conclusion: A universal God wouldn’t speak through a narrow, localized medium — a human religious invention would.

❓ 11. Why does Islam give women half the legal worth of men?

Quran 2:282 – Two women’s testimony = one man.
Quran 4:11 – Women inherit half.

This isn’t cultural — it’s divine law.

📌 Trap: Either Allah is just and these laws are fair, or Islam enshrines systemic gender inequality.

❓ 12. Why did Muhammad perform no miracles?

The Quran repeatedly denies miracles:

Quran 17:59 – “Nothing stops Us from sending signs except that the former peoples denied them.”
Quran 6:37, 29:50 – People demanded signs; Muhammad gave none.

Muslims later invented miracle stories in Hadith — but the Quran contradicts them.

📌 Conclusion: Either the Quran is wrong, or the Hadith are fabricated.

❓ 13. If Hadiths are unreliable, why base law on them?

Muslims reject Hadiths about stoning, wife-beating, or violent jihad as “weak.”
But Islamic law is 90% Hadith-based.

📌 Trap: If Hadiths are unreliable, Sharia collapses. If they’re reliable, Islam is exposed.

❓ 14. Why does Islam enforce a punishment (stoning) that isn’t in the Quran?

Quran 24:2 – For adultery: 100 lashes.
Hadith – For adultery: stoning to death.

The stoning verse was allegedly “revealed” but then eaten by a goat (Sunan Ibn Majah 1944).

📌 Conclusion: Either the Quran is incomplete, or Islamic law overrides divine scripture.

❓ 15. Why is Islam’s God so different from the God of the Bible if He’s supposedly the same?

The God of the Bible:

Loves unconditionally,
Offers grace and forgiveness,
Does not demand compulsion or conquest.

The Allah of the Quran:

Is unknowable,
Demands obedience through fear and violence,
Denies Jesus’ divinity and crucifixion.

📌 Conclusion: These are not the same God. The Quran either misrepresents God—or invented a new one.

🧠 Final Analysis

These questions don’t require insults, emotion, or interpretation.
They just require honesty and logic.

Any system that cannot survive its own scripture collapses under its own weight.
Islam, when held to its own standard, destroys itself.